THE KAOBOYS OF R&AW PDF
The Kaoboys & R&AW book. Read 43 reviews from the world's largest community for readers. This book deals largely with those aspects of the working of the. [cittadelmonte.info97] The Kaoboys & R&AW: Down Memory Lane The Kaoboys & R&AW: B. Raman epub. The Kaoboys & R&AW: B. Raman pdf download. The Kaoboys. How We Killed The Kaoboys Mallika Nawal| Date Feb, and B. Raman's memoir titled The Kaoboys of R&AW: Down Memory Lane.
|Language:||English, Spanish, Dutch|
|Genre:||Fiction & Literature|
|ePub File Size:||22.54 MB|
|PDF File Size:||17.15 MB|
|Distribution:||Free* [*Regsitration Required]|
Raman One that you have to consistently bear in mind is that reviewing e-book The Kaoboys Of R&AW: Down Memory Lane By B. RAMAN PDF Considering that . RAMAN PDF. Merely connect to the net to obtain this book The Kaoboys Of R&AW: Down Memory Lane By B. Raman This is why we suggest. This Book Review is brought to you for free and open access by the Journals at U.S. Naval War College Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in.
Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read. Want to Read saving…. Want to Read Currently Reading Read. Other editions. Enlarge cover. Error rating book.
We are indebted. Raman is quite unapologetic about his admiration for the Gandhis, and credits them for what India's intelligence agencies are today.
He also laments that these agencies were unable to protect both Indira Gandhi and Rajiv Gandhi, to whom they owed a lot for their existence. The only major point of dissent that I have with the author is regarding the Ayodhya issue. He argues that Muslims in India have not taken to widespread violence until their sentiments were hurt due to Babri-Masjid demolition, Raman is quite unapologetic about his admiration for the Gandhis, and credits them for what India's intelligence agencies are today.
He argues that Muslims in India have not taken to widespread violence until their sentiments were hurt due to Babri-Masjid demolition, and squarely blames the Hindu community for hurting Muslim sentiments, which is quite erroneous and historically untrue. Apr 29, Venkateswaran rated it it was ok. An average book The narrative is discontinuous, most events described are trivial. I had always imagined RAW to be very good, because no one knew anything about it.
As a secret service it may have been better that way. But having known a few things more about it after this book, am not sure whether I should have read the book in the first place. The hype over the book and the author himself did have their influence on me. Finally, ended up reading the Kindle version. If I can summarize Raman's book, I say its a 'too clever by half' attempt! Why do I say that? And its not to suggest that Raman's book is thrash or not to be read at all.
It has its importance, there are facts revealed which were unknown hitherto and new perspectives on our polity, intelligence apparatus and incidents. It is the unbridled sanctimonious importance that he grants himself and constant attempts to blame everyone else is one of my pain points. The other agony I had to experience throughout the work is his fawning obsequiousness of the Gandhi Family.
He almost grants the entire bouquets of goods that happened to India and the Intelligence community to Indira and Rajiv Gandhi and the anything bad to everyone else! I mean if this was how a intelligence officer was enamored by a political family, what is the guarantee that it has not affected his sensibilities and decision making abilities? Fathom this: He credits Indira Gandhi for her role in the successful intelligence operations during war and many quoted incidents later.
However, no such words of praise are directed towards VP Singh or Chandrashekar for their support to the intelligence agencies during the Khalistani movement or in Kashmir.
All success after Indira credited only to the intelligence officers while they duly deserve while every success earlier has been lavishly credited by the author to Indira and her son. Even after his retirement, there are instances he quotes where successful diplomatic maneuvers were credited to PVN Rao and Manmohan Singh. However, there are no words of praise for AB Vajpayee for his role in Pokhran-II tests or other successful diplomatic victories.
His hatred towards 'Hindutva' emerges several times in the book.
Maybe this ensured his dislike for Vajpayee and Hindu organizations. Worst and most unexpected of a intelligence officer is like mainstream media, he squarely blames the rise of Islamic terrorism in India to the demolition of Babri Masjid!
He hints that if the Babri Masjid wasn't brought down, Islamic terrorism would have spared India altogether. As I read through his analysis of post Babri incidents, a sense of despondency crept inside. If this is how our ace intelligence officers analyse issues in a partisan manner, would it be any different today?
The threats have increased. Ways to target India have grown manifold. But have our intelligence officers and their apparatus upgraded themselves? Or do they still believe that making notes regularly is good enough to thwart terrorist attacks? Few amusing incidents Eg. I have always loved to read about the working of Intelligence agencies and their role in real.
I would rate Peter Wrights 'Spycatcher' and Maj. Alas, the Indian versions are too costly hence waiting for the low cost edition to be out sometime.
The Kaoboys & R&AW: Down Memory Lane by B. Raman
Also wondering is Allen Dulles 'Craft of Intelligence' is still relevant in modern times. Dont want to read about the survival capacity of a Dodo: Nov 07, Mihir Parekh rated it really liked it. Functioning of agency under different Prime Minister provides valuable inputs while evaluating performance of various Prime Ministers in terms of dealing with external and internal security problems.
Irony and dilemmas of intelligence agencies of world, Role of ISI, CIA and intelligence agencies of other countries in context of India, their liasoning network and their functioning are narrated, though not so lucidly, which provides glimpse in this secret world. However, some time book looks unorganized and author seems to wandering like spy, in toto, book provide good overall picture. B Raman does not forget to mention Late Shakti Bhatt, daughter of famous Gujarati writer Kanti Bhatt who died at young age of 26 due to brief illness, on whose insistence he agreed to write this book.
Plenty of anecdotes, honest narrative and more than any other thing, subject of book itself makes this book highly readable. Apr 05, Srinivas rated it it was ok. I was always curious to read about India's spy agency - and its worthiness.
This book is first hand description of how RAW works, its history and procedures, and justifications for failures. The paragraphs are repetitive at a times and opinions are more inclined towards cynicism. Perhaps just impressions of a retired spy. If you are expecting a story similar to what ex-spies from Mossad, CIA or MI6 have written - then this book is not even close.
The book does not discuss details of the covert o I was always curious to read about India's spy agency - and its worthiness. It glosses over key information elements of so called "spy agency" of India.
[H577.eBook] Download PDF the Kaoboys of Raw Down Memory Lane by B Raman
Good read if you can relate to the events described in the book and are interested in feeble spy operations of countries like India. Jun 30, Vishaka Datta rated it liked it.
Raman has written extensively on Indian security matters for a while now, as well as being a guest on numerous TV debates on the subject.
There are few such accounts mentioned in the book. Instead, the book provides a broad overview of the history of RAW's role i B. Instead, the book provides a broad overview of the history of RAW's role in Indian policy and shaping relationships with its neighbours, as well as providing extensive details of the thinking of various prime ministers, from Indira Gandhi who helped birth RAW from IB, all the way to the government of Narasimha Rao.
In terms of analyzing the relationship between RAW, the government, and other agencies, I found this book to be an eye-opener in understanding the frequent conflicts that arise between them. Raman also consistently puts forward his views on various policies and problems that have plagued RAW through the decades, without which the book would merely be a loose collection of anecdotes.
The book is littered with incomplete anecdotes, however, not to mention curiously bad editing and grammar for someone who possessed a BA in journalism.
The other major drawback is the lack of a larger context provided to many of the events and episodes highlighted through the book. Raman writes purely as an analyst, and never once tries to portray the humanity of the spies involved, or the people affected by the actions of RAW or other intelligence agencies. If this is what you're looking for, this is not the book for the job. Raman starts with analyzing the role of RAW in the war which saw Bangladesh break off from Pakistan.
This was crucial in garnering diplomatic support for India's actions in Bangladesh, much to the consternation of the US and Pakistan. Also highlighted is the carrying out of "covert actions" in northern Burma during this war, which played a role in curbing the activities of the Mizo National Front MNF under Laldenga. Raman highlights the role played by RAW in setting the stage for negotiations that ultimately brought an end to insurgency by the MNF.
This was an insurgency that saw sufficient violence and bloodshed from all sides involved, and Raman stays mum on all of it. Raman highlights the role played by the ISI and China in supporting these insurgencies through providing arms and training, and the non-cooperation of the Burmese Army. These claims are hard to verify for me, based as they are on classified information.
But this is true of much of what is said in the book. Raman moves on to talk about the Khalistani movement, which along with the portions dealing with terrorism, forms a considerable chunk of the book. Again, the role of the ISI aside, supported as it was from Zia ul Haq in its policies, Raman fumes at the turned gaze of the CIA, MI6 and Canadian intelligence agencies while Khalistani militants brazenly moved across borders to organize support for their movement.
It's hard for me to believe that any intelligence agency would have the power to foment such an organized movement single handedly without any help from other sources of disgruntlement amongst the Sikh population.
How We Killed The Kaoboys
To that end, Raman insists that the lack of help provided to Sikhs abroad on the same lines that Israel provides to Jews also helped build up support for Khalistan.
But again, this seems far-fetched. Raman provides a blanket denial of these allegations, but rarely addresses them head on or clear the air about them.
Nonetheless, Desai's distrust saw many of RAW's capabilities blunted as manpower had to be fired or re-assigned, and missions scaled back. But interestingly, Raman points out to the rot that had already set in to RAW. Nepotistic appointments, lavish lifestyles led by RAW officers abroad, reports of RAW agents harassing Indians abroad dulled the post sheen of the organization.
But Raman says that though the RAW chiefs appointed by every successive governments were remarkably upright individuals, they seemed to turn a blind eye, or were outright ineffective, in dealing with these matters. Through each of these chapters, Raman brings out the intricacies and counter-intuitive nature of intelligence work.
These are the few nuggets that are great takeaways from the book. Often, it seems that when we thinking about American involvement in an issue, different arms of the country have their own agendas. Or the unwritten rules about spying, like the idea that liaison officers of an agency aren't supposed to spy on the countries they're posted in, or that host countries aren't supposed to ill-treat spies discovered in the embassy of a friendly nation which ISI and IB reportedly never follow.
These are the places of the book where the macabre world of spycraft are written for all to see. Raman goes into considerable detail about the days and weeks leading up to the asssassination of Indira Gandhi. Pointing to the lack of coordination between the RAW, IB and Delhi Police, Raman sketches a depressing picture of the state of information sharing between agencies.
The fact that intelligence agency failures are highlighted, and successes kept classified, creates an incentive for intelligence agencies to over-hype or exaggerate perceived threats, lest they be held accountable for a failure. Conflicting reports on threats to a VIP are commonplace, as is the issue of common sources being used by multiple agencies which means information provided by different agencies is rarely independent, or that turf wars between agencies remain a blight.
Throw in a sense of competition between agencies to be the first to report a threat, and it's a miracle that any VIP stays alive! From Desai's lack of support of the RAW, through Rajiv Gandhi's continuation of Indira's patronage of the institution, down to Rao and Singh's grudging appreciation of its work, the RAW suffered from many flaws which could have been addressed by the prime ministers of the day. Aside from those mentioned earlier, rivalry with other agencies, a lack of oversight of the agency by the parliament compared to the practice in the US and most democracies elsewhere , troubles in preventing major attacks and issues with gathering certain kinds of human intelligence continue to plague the agency.
Counter-intelligence remains a concern as there have been numerous instances of moles penetrating the PMO and RAW itself. Nepotism in recruitments still continue, thanks to its exemption from recruiting through the UPSC. Raman bemoans the fact that successes from an agency can never be publicized while failures can, which contributes to an impression of ineptitude about the capabilities of the RAW and IB. But it's also clear that the Indian government's refusal to declassify reports from way back when also contribute hugely to our lack of awareness of past successes of the RAW.
Raman claims that the RAW's archives contain plenty of material for any future historian, but whether such a historian would be allowed to freely write remains unclear. Perhaps political parties fear the confirmation of allegations of RAW and IB's complicity in spying on the opposition coming to light.
Or perhaps that the archives are woefully incomplete and disorganized. Either way, the RAW remains an organization that is shrouded in perhaps a little too much secrecy as Raman points out, and this need for excess secrecy continues to be its undoing even today. Aug 10, Shailesh Nadar rated it liked it.
The book can be broadly divided into two parts — the Kao era and the post Kao era. The best part of the book is the surprising lack of jingoism and how it de-glamorizes the role of a spy. It is much less of planned assassinations, police chases in the enemy country etc. He is ruthless in relatively minor misgivings of the governments of Morarji Desai, VP Singh and Chandrashekar, while casually grazes over the horrendous episodes of emergency and the Bofors scandal.
Finally the book seems to be hastily edited as phrases and bits of information repeat at multiple places in the book. The individual chapters sometimes feel like more of a haphazard collection of thoughts than a coherent narrative.
Overall, an interesting book, though feels like a drag in bits. Dec 29, Kaustubh Kirti rated it liked it Shelves: The book is a detailed account of RAW and how it operates. Going into various working and functionings of the organisation the author has tried to walk the reader through the s,80s and early 90s of how RAW operated under several PM and how it changes bumper to bumper.
Interesting inside information is available with pace and fast changing story landscape. What is however missing is probably the James Bond scene you expect out of this book. Book is a very interesting read and many of the incid The book is a detailed account of RAW and how it operates.
Book is a very interesting read and many of the incidents like the assassination of Rajiv and Indira Gandhi and the Khalistan Movement are covered in detail.
OPerational challenges and details which might not be available otherwise are up for grabs. Aug 28, Chintan Shah rated it really liked it. This book is good. Who all if not everybody contributed to maintain inernal peace and thwart external threats against India. Though at times I felt as if, while writing and sharing his experience, author was lost in multiple thoughts; as if certain things he fe This book is good.
Though at times I felt as if, while writing and sharing his experience, author was lost in multiple thoughts; as if certain things he felt like sharing with readers but was too cautious perhaps?
So he just drew outline. Because of that this book raises so many questions, and because of this one will read more. Dig more. Questions like: No mention of Mr. Oct 29, thought rated it it was amazing. Great account of how the agency works by an ex official at highest levels.
It discusses about the agency's successes, failures, lack of man management, attitude of permissiveness which led to rise of moles, functioning under different governments. The book cou Great account of how the agency works by an ex official at highest levels. The book could've been better edited but that doesn't hamper reading.
I finished in one go, real page turner! May 06, Tim rated it really liked it. At times though it felt like flipping through a history text book. But I must complement the author in bringing out the gruelling truth about the history of the terrorism as we currently know. Overall, it's a nice read if you're enthusiastic about knowing about the shaping of the nation post independence till the early when the author retired from his office.
Rambling narrative, quite open and blatant The cats let out of the bag, seem quite tame. The skeletons in the closet are more about misgivings rather than haunting. The Kaoboys lived in the Eastman color Nehruvision era and overawed by powerful political players of those times. Oct 23, Anirudas rated it really liked it. Jun 04, Ashutosh Dwivedi rated it liked it. A restrictive perspective with repetition of instances. The book is full about the details of turf wars and only talks cursorily about the work of the agency and when it does mostly in anecdotal terms.
Nov 21, Tmk rated it really liked it. A wonderful first hand acct by a spy. It gives an idea about the working system of Indian external intelligence. Though deserved for all round appreciation for their undercover activities usefulj for the country, these spies remain low profile in the eyes of public. Nov 15, Govind Nigam rated it it was amazing. Jan 19, Vaasu Sharma rated it it was amazing. Mar 07, Vipin rated it really liked it. Not very discriptive about operations but definitly gives an insight of the agency.
Dec 08, Ravi Singh rated it really liked it. I was introduced to Late B. Raman sir by the website: This makes it difficult to read at times.
The book is written in a kind of flashback. He also offers a perspective on what RAW needs to do in future. Apart from this. Gandhi had her own staff pay customs duty for smuggling in goods from a foreign trip with her..
The Kaoboys & R&AW: Down Memory Lane
In the world of spies. The book is mostly quite sober. Again this comes through in quite a balanced manner.. Each topic is dealt with in a fairly detailed manner. Most helpful customer reviews 7 of 8 people found the following review helpful. There are 19 chapters in all. The type face is good There is a lot of useful information. At places he offers interesting tidbits. He also shares his perspective on how the vanity and foibles of our leaders were manipulated or affected the country.
His focus remains throughout on protecting Indian territory and interests. In between. Raman retired from the service. The book has been printed on expensive. No initiatives.
We ended up having a nuclear armed Pakistan and an ill-disposed Bangladesh in the neighborhood. Worth pondering this thought as well. He avers that. It started as early as when Naga rebels crossed over to Burma to get trained in rebellion. Pakistan provided honor and support to Dr Jagjit Singh Chauhan and helped him conduct his Khalistan movement even prior to the war. No discussions on "non-white papers".
Pakistan's relationship with India was at its worst when Benazir headed Pakistan. Failure by New Delhi to stop the alienation of Kashmir Muslims unlike the successful stopping of the alienation of Sikhs in Punjab thanks to several leaders amongst the valiant Sikhs themselves. At last some of our sleuths have started publishing books about their life and times in RAW. Pakistan found a greater success in Kashmir because of: Raman does not succumb to the temptation of spilling secrets.
Nor does he think the win against Soviets provided US any strategic advantage. The rebels' dream of a Greater Nagaland.
No meetings. CIA was wary of Indian sleuths helping Soviets in Afghanistan and kept them busy by supporting the Khalistan movement.
Pakistan helped Mizo rebel Laldenga conduct a campaign from Pakistan for Mizo separatism. Prime Minister V P Singh had to pay the price eventually and 4. Worth pondering this thought. Benazir Bhutto's stepped up support to ISI with unlimited power and required funds to conduct the proxy war. Availability of He provides the insightful analysis one can expect from him: Raman is convinced that "if ever there is an attack in US soil using a weapon of mass destruction. Strategic interests dominate everything else.
India is always able to get good leaders at political level. It has been infiltrated by foreign intelligence agencies over the years. Girish Saxena.. Organizing the nation's sleuths blending the plays abroad. Prime Minister Chandrasekar secretly agreed to refuel US aircrafts proceeding to the Gulf war theater in According to him.
Bahukutumbi Raman is a former head of the counter-terrorism division of India's external intelligence agency. But not without its potshots and settling scores. Raman's book clearly brings out the stellar role Kao's men played in serving India's territorial integrity and geopolitical interests..
The book traces the origins of RAW from its inception. Several bureaucrats had fallen prey to money. Interspersed are accounts of both the development and decline of India's intelligence gathering capabilities. Prime Minister Indira Gandhi. Let wisdom prevail over interests and transparency prevail over power in organizing our intelligence forces. It is somewhat sad and disappointing that the RAW.
Lawrence Wright. He died of cancer during the second term of Reagan.. The Government of India immediately shared the information with US officials and pointed that it was a fit case for declaring Pakistan a State-sponsor of international terrorism..
The Looming Tower. Lawrence Wright's book however skirts the entire episode of US participation and involvement in the training. This has continued since then. Raman reveals more.. Pakistan's support - military. During his secret visits to the terrorist training camps and madrassas in Pakistan in the s. Casey used to address the trainees as "My sons".
This has been sore point with Indians.. B Raman essentially states that the spectre of terrorism that haunts the West is more or less a creation of the West.
Some of the retired CIA officers of those days.. Even though she had tried to stop the ISI's assistance to the Khalistani terrorists during her first tenure as the Prime Minister between and This book feels very "skimmy". Provides a fairly good and broad overview of RAW and some historical perspective on the challenges faced by India. This terrible loss at the hands of India obviously left a deep and permanent mark on Benazir Bhutto.
Part of this may be because of the nature of the disclosures. An overkill surely. The style of writing is very much declarative.. Jihadi terrorism. No one topic is covered in much depth. See all 19 customer reviews.
If you want me to drop the Sikh card This may be by design.. Benazir Bhutto was the daughter of the late Zulfikar Ali Bhtto..
Gul replied: She desperately wanted to be the daughter that win the war that her father had lost. The book.. Some of the chapters..
By in this manner. Exactly what do you think of our idea right here? You could take the benefits as well as share it additionally for your pals and people around you. Raman is not only for your duties or requirement in your life. Raman profitably. Publications will always be a buddy in every time you check out.
Flag for inappropriate content. Related titles. Intelligence and Security Committee of Parliament: Annual report